Border Czar Tom Homan Asked Point Blank: Should Birthright Citizenship Be Changed?

2 days ago

At an event with Gov. Ron DeSantis (R-FL) at the New College of Florida, Border Czar Tom Homan gave his take on birthright citizenship.

Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:

https://account.forbes.com/membership/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=display&utm_campaign=growth_non-sub_paid_subscribe_ytdescript

Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: http://fb.com/forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: http://instagram.com/forbes
More From Forbes: http://forbes.com

Transcript

00:00of history it means you really are on the right side of history the having

00:04said that though the incentives are a real issue and I think the biggest

00:07incentive and I'll go to you czar what about birthright citizenship I mean you

00:13just get across the border you get here and then you're and you're born here

00:17you're a citizen is that something that needs to change well say this is an

00:23enticement it's a magnet for more illegal immigration for example under

00:29President Obama a lot of families came across a lot of single females came

00:37across and Jay Johnson was the secretary at the time and I respect Jay Johnson

00:43didn't agree with him all the time but yeah his door is always open he heard me

00:47out right so despite all the hate on Trump President Obama approved a family

00:54operation where these family groups who've been ordered removed because they

00:57lost her case and 90% of people claim asylum at the border will end up with

01:02order removal because they simply don't qualify for asylum they're coming here

01:06for a better life I get that but they're not escaping fear and persecution from

01:09their home government because of the race religion political affiliation to

01:13make a fraudulent asylum claim so we had hundreds of family units that were

01:16already moved by the judge the Obama administration approved us to go look

01:20for these people and deport them we went looking for them 44% of these family

01:27units the the mother's already had a US citizen child or was pregnant with a US

01:32citizen child despite all the hate that's out there and people attacking

01:36this that is a driver for illegal immigration because they say illegal

01:39aliens don't take social benefits why argue with I've been doing this a long

01:42time to do but having US citizen increases the use of social services and

01:48it's it's a driver of illegal immigration birthright citizenship Russia

01:52and China the two biggest countries where they come here on a visa visit visa

01:56tourist visa and they're pregnant they have a US citizen child while they're

01:59here they're not here for the tourist or visitor here to have a child and become

02:04a US citizen so I think the Supreme Court finally needs to answer that

02:06question you know I'm not a lawyer but I can read I don't think it's clear that

02:11illegal alien that you know has a child in this country is automatically a US

02:16citizen when they talk to keep calling back to the Wong case the one was

02:20actually here under immigration control we they were here legally and they

02:26weren't citizens but they're here legally we're here under the control of

02:28the government so we'll see what Supreme Court says I hope the Supreme Court will

02:32decide the right way but I have seen the same fears you have but it's a driver

02:37really immigration and here's where I need to be people understand I know I

02:40got some haters out there and I'd love that because I'm not running a

02:45popularity contest when people saying this is just innocent illegal immigration

02:49there is no such thing because you wore my shoes for 34 years there's a whole

02:54under ugly underbelly of illegal immigration 31% of women make their

02:59journey get sexually assaulted fact well I'm talking to you right now women are

03:04being sexually assaulted as part of their fee to cross the border luckily

03:09because of President Trump and bored down 96% unless that's happening but

03:13illegal immigration is not a victimless crime I've done it for a long time and

03:19it's right way and wrong way to enter the greatest country on earth we got

03:23millions of people standing in line taking her test doing their background

03:26investigation paying the fees they're sitting in the backseat while millions

03:31of people in the Biden administration cheated the system they can claim their

03:35asylum seekers all they want okay they're seeking asylum well here's what

03:39you need to understand nearly 90% of everybody claims asylum our southern

03:43border end up with the order removal which is why we need to do a massive

03:48deportation operation everybody said well what a racist thing to say no when

03:52you have a massive illegal alien crisis on our southern border by the millions

03:57and we know 90% don't qualify for asylum people on the left can say they have a

04:03right to claim asylum they have a right to see a judge they have a right to due

04:06process and we made that happen but due process doesn't mean squat if the final

04:13decision the courts isn't carried out and executed that's what due process is

04:17so since 90% of millions of people came across the border be order removed those

04:21orders asked be executed if they're not executed and what the hell are we doing

04:25just shut down immigration court doesn't mean anything anymore take the board

04:29draw off the border we need to send a message to the whole world there's a

04:32right way and wrong way to come to this country there's a legal way to do it

04:37you want to be part of the greatest nation on earth breaking our law

04:40shouldn't be the first thing you do

04:48I mean I think the biggest enticement to come is employment and then in place

04:55like California benefits like taxpayer benefits but I think birthright

04:59citizenship is also an enticement and and that was not what the 14th Amendment

05:04was ever intended to do with respect to illegally crossing the border and then

05:09giving birth here in the United States the purpose of the 14th Amendment was to

05:13overturn the Dred Scott case which said that basically blacks could not be US

05:19citizens Dred Scott was a freed slave he sued the Supreme Court said he can't be

05:24considered a citizen Lincoln rightfully attacked that ruling Lincoln was not

05:31even gonna he said that you shouldn't comply with the ruling you know you hear

05:34some of these people talk oh they're not following corridors read what Lincoln

05:37said about Dred Scott Lincoln did not submit to Dred Scott and so when you had

05:43time for the 14th Amendment that was written in there to to nullify the Dred

05:48Scott decision and that was specifically meant to deal with the issue of

05:53African Americans particularly after after the abolition of slavery now and

05:58Tom makes a good point because in law school we're even taught oh the Supreme

06:02Court's already decided anyone born here is a citizen and you and I and I used to

06:07think that was the law until I started really looking at it but this Wong Kim

06:12case from the 1880s or 90s you had two Chinese nationals who legally immigrated

06:19to the United States and then they had a and then they said under those

06:22circumstances that that was birthright but that's a lot different than people

06:26coming in contrary to what the law is where the the American people have never

06:32through their elected representatives provided that pathway to come just

06:36across the border so it's definitely a live issue I think the Supreme Court

06:41will will tackle it look I don't know that I would be heavily optimistic that

06:48they'll rule the right way I think it's possible but I think it's very much a

06:52jump ball we know how three of them will rule the opposite they will say you know

06:58as long as you get across you get across that border illegally a minute later give

07:01birth there say that's what the Constitution somehow was supposed to be

07:04we know that's not what what what is there and it's not honestly what the

07:07text says but it is going to be it is going to be litigated I think the

07:11president was right to do the executive order he knew that this was going to end

07:15up in the courts and and that's that's fine I mean this this this is the type

07:20of an issue where a Supreme Court would end up having the ability to pass a

07:24judgment on but let's just be clear how this has developed over the last many

07:29decades no one at the time the 14th Amendment was ratified would have said

07:35that was appropriate and if you had told them that's what was going to happen the

07:3914th Amendment as written would not have even been ratified yeah I agree I think

07:44this idea that and I think President Trump was in his team was very smart you

07:50know the executive order is is very specific about birthright citizenship and

07:54they knew it was going to get into the court so I certainly agree with that but

07:57they they started focusing on those folks that come to the United States

08:00illegally and whether they have or their children have a right to citizenship here

08:04and I think that is something that certainly needs to be decided but Tom

08:08brought it up and the governor's brought it up this idea that you have a right to

08:12asylum or you have a right to a student visa right the Columbia student who is

08:16being deported or that you have a right to a green card I think the left has

08:20misconstrued that for so long you don't have a right to any of that that is a

08:24benefit that is a discretionary benefit that the United States government

08:27provides you and embedded in that are restrictions and things that you need to

08:32do to adhere to that and so this idea that you can't deport students or this

08:38idea that you can't deny green cards or even remove people with green cards of

08:41course you can that's a discretionary benefit in immigration law that the

08:46United States government provides and when you don't adhere to certain

08:49principles and certain requirements well guess what you don't have a right to

08:52that that can be withdrawn and you can be removed so a lot of this that that

08:58we've talked about here is just getting the American people to think about what

09:01they've been sort of told for so long people have a right to certain things

09:05actually if you look at the law which Tom and others do quite often that's

09:10actually not the case and I think what President Trump and the team is doing

09:14this time around we did it what I call Trump 1.0 we did it there as well as

09:19actually looking at the law and actually adhering to the law and administrating

09:23an immigration system how it was supposed to be designed not how it's

09:28been conceived over over many decades

Border Czar Tom Homan Asked Point Blank: Should Birthright Citizenship Be Changed?

Category

Transcript

Recommended