مدي 1 تي في : خطة جامعية لتطوير التحكيم المغربي - 19/03/2025
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:30in the presence of representatives of the national gang and the national board of judges and the central committee of judges.
00:38The university confirmed in an official statement that the Moroccan-American judge will carry out a comprehensive experience of the national judge system,
00:47including the full strength, weakness and suggestions of ways to develop it.
00:52Ismail has become an international judge in 2016,
00:55as he participated in the 2019 World Cup under 20 years,
01:00in addition to the 2019 World Cup in India and the 2022 World Cup in Qatar,
01:08as well as his management of several competitions in the professional American state and the Concacaf Gold Cup.
01:15Let's talk about this specific topic.
01:20We are pleased to have with us the journalist and journalist Mohamed Miftaha.
01:24Simi Mohamed, welcome.
01:26Welcome, Khair Faisal, and welcome to all the followers of the Media Handel channel.
01:31Welcome.
01:32So, Mr. Miftaha, the university assigns Ismail Al-Fatih to carry out a comprehensive experience of the national judge system.
01:40In your opinion, Simi Mohamed, what is the purpose of this appointment?
01:45I think, as I have confirmed and emphasized, the protests of the national judges in many competitions
01:52show that there is a lack of judgment,
01:55but we can say that it would have been better if this initiative or this step was taken at the beginning of the season.
02:01But today, even at this time, it can be an addition,
02:04considering that today we are using the experience of the original Moroccan,
02:08as Ismail Al-Fatih said,
02:10that he was raised in the city of Dar Al-Bayda.
02:13He knows the customs and even the Moroccan mentality.
02:18These are things that will help us find where the error is.
02:22Knowing that when we talk about the Moroccan judiciary,
02:25the Moroccan judiciary is not at the level of technical or administrative.
02:29There are things that may make the judge make wrong decisions,
02:34which are far from what is technical.
02:37This is what made the Moroccan Royal Society of Soccer,
02:40led by Mr. Fouzi Al-Qajar,
02:42to take the initiative because they were a group of civil servants,
02:45a group of international judges,
02:47who we could use at this stage.
02:50But we can consider that it is smart of the society
02:54to go and bring a judge who knows the Moroccan mentality,
02:59who knows how to communicate easily between the central committee and the manager,
03:06because according to his statement,
03:09he said that with the help of Mr. Erdogan,
03:13as well as Mr. Harash,
03:15they will find where the error is.
03:17Here we can say that this process,
03:19this matter of communication,
03:21made it easier for us to find the error,
03:24which we think is a logical error,
03:28not a technical error.
03:30When we see the judges playing matches on the ground level,
03:33their performance may be good,
03:35but the question is,
03:37why do we have problems on our championship level?
03:40Here we can ask this question,
03:42but the most important thing
03:44is to reach this level,
03:46between us and the judges,
03:48with each other,
03:50there may be discussions of the group,
03:52which we can say is a team,
03:54a group that has been practicing for a long time,
03:57there are judges you can find,
03:59for example, in the season of 17 matches,
04:01one you can find only 6,
04:03these things, for me,
04:05in my point of view,
04:07make the disputes between the judges
04:09secret,
04:11which affects the level of the matches.
04:13So, we can say that,
04:15we hope that the opening will be successful,
04:17even if it is a short period of time,
04:19because when you come and tell me,
04:21I want you to find me where the error is,
04:23here in the judging system,
04:25it is very difficult,
04:27as they say,
04:29between a month and a half,
04:31to reach this level,
04:33to reach a conclusion,
04:35that Morocco has the power,
04:37has the judges at the level,
04:39only the most important thing
04:41is to reach our level,
04:43which we can say,
04:45we can all talk about,
04:47Mr. Saeed Belkoula,
04:49may God have mercy on him.
04:51Yes, may God have mercy on Saeed Belkoula,
04:53who won the World Cup in 1998,
04:55between France and Brazil,
04:57in addition to all the gifts
04:59that you gave to Morocco,
05:01how will Ismail's experience help
05:03in the opening,
05:05which he won in different World Cups
05:07in Qatar,
05:09for example,
05:11in obtaining the judging skills
05:13of the Moroccan judges in particular?
05:15You, brother Faisal,
05:17at the beginning of the episode,
05:19you talked about what happened
05:21to Mr. Saeed,
05:23the matches in Qatar,
05:25the World Cup in India,
05:27and all these things gave him
05:29an opportunity
05:31to know
05:33the problem of judging in general.
05:35In addition to that,
05:37the important point that I mentioned
05:39is that he is originally Moroccan,
05:41it is very easy for him to communicate
05:43with the judges,
05:45because even in the American role,
05:47he always has a relationship
05:49with the national championship,
05:51he follows, watches, discusses
05:53the topics of judging
05:55and even the discussion
05:57during the meeting
05:59between him and the president
06:01of the university and the members
06:03of the board of directors
06:05and the members of the Central Committee
06:07showed that there is a connection
06:09between him and the judges.
06:11It is very difficult
06:13to find this connection
06:15between Leila and Duhal.
06:17It takes a long time
06:19to find this connection.
06:21But I think that today
06:23when we talk about judging in general,
06:25we find a lot of things.
06:27It is not possible to talk about it today
06:29only at the level of prison and jail,
06:31but we have been talking about it
06:33for years.
06:35For example, we have a lecture
06:37in FIFA.
06:39It is not possible that we have
06:41these qualities and qualities
06:43that we can say that we have
06:45and we have this problem.
06:47The problem we have is not a technical problem.
06:49The problem is easy to find.
06:51We just need to give these judges
06:53what they need.
06:55But today judges find problems
06:57only at the level of communication.
06:59They find problems at the level of
07:01the game management.
07:03This is one of the things
07:05that we say is very important
07:07and very easy to overcome.
07:09I just wish that this decision
07:11would be made at the beginning of the season
07:13because now we will not have enough time
07:15for the system to give us the result
07:17in two months.
07:19We are not just talking about
07:21the first national division.
07:23We are talking about the ruling
07:25of the first national division,
07:27the second national division
07:29and even the rest of the gangs.
07:31This responsibility will be
07:33heavy on Judge Ismail Fathou.
07:35But what gave me a little rest
07:37is his speech and his honesty
07:39that he said that there will be
07:41a joint work of all the prisons
07:43and jails.
07:45These things give us confidence
07:47that there will be a solution.
07:49Mr. Mohamed, before we continue
07:51our discussion,
07:53let's follow what Judge Ismail Fathou
07:55said after he was commissioned
07:57to develop the system
07:59of the Moroccan judges at the university.
08:01First of all, I would like to thank
08:03the president for this invitation.
08:05It is a great honor
08:07that my country invited me
08:09to work with the sports organization
08:11here.
08:13Secondly, I congratulate everyone
08:15for their achievements.
08:17It is a great honor that we,
08:19as Moroccans, are fighting abroad
08:21and we see our country in the middle.
08:23As for the project,
08:25it is a project of experience
08:27and evaluation.
08:29It is a project of the
08:31Moroccan judicial system
08:33with a new vision,
08:35the vision that I live with
08:37in the professional judicial system
08:39that we have in America
08:41for more than 12 years now.
08:43It is a project of international cooperation
08:45as a consultant of the judicial system
08:47in many universities.
08:49First of all, it is my country.
08:51The evaluation will be
08:53a partnership with the brothers
08:55of Mr. Erdogan and Mr. Al-Harsh
08:57with their participation
08:59and we will exchange opinions
09:01and come up with a decision.
09:05Let's go back to you again,
09:07Mr. Meftah.
09:09After the commissioning of the university
09:11and the opening of this mission,
09:13there was a discussion
09:15that the decision of the university
09:17that specializes in Moroccan judicial system,
09:19Mr. Meftah,
09:21may be an acknowledgement
09:23based on the national judicial system.
09:25Do you agree with this opinion?
09:27I think so.
09:29Of course.
09:31When we heard the statements
09:33of the head of the national professional
09:35judicial system,
09:37he said,
09:39even if the university is the one
09:41that appoints,
09:43he said that
09:45one of the reasons
09:47that made us support
09:49the opening of the university
09:51is the public protests.
09:53The most prominent is the protest
09:55of the sports team.
09:57These are the words of the official,
09:59not the words of someone
10:01who is only a member of the sports system.
10:03Today, there are mistakes.
10:05This is a fact.
10:07This is a repetition of the problem.
10:09Today, when there is a mistake,
10:11Mr. Faisal,
10:13you find that the decision of the university
10:15is a mistake.
10:17This increases the situation.
10:19It is not possible that
10:21I sit in front of a screen
10:23and stop the decision
10:25that I made
10:27in the university.
10:29It is not possible to say
10:31that it is a normal mistake.
10:33It is possible to say that we have an error.
10:35It is possible that we have an error
10:37with Mr. Ismail.
10:39Maybe when the judge
10:41is not happy with the room of the bar,
10:43you say that it is up to the judge.
10:45But today, when the judge
10:47has a decision,
10:49for example,
10:51the room of the bar
10:53may intervene at a time
10:55when the decision was clear.
10:57In some cases,
10:59he may intervene
11:01and give a decision
11:03to the judge.
11:05The problem today
11:07is the communication
11:09between the judges
11:11of the room of the bar
11:13and the judges of the field
11:15or the judges of the field.
11:17We have a big problem
11:19with this issue.
11:21When you ask anyone
11:23who follows football
11:25and who loves it,
11:27the judges feel that
11:29they do not agree with each other.
11:31These things
11:33that the audience feels
11:35make us feel
11:37that there is a conspiracy
11:39and that there is nothing behind it.
11:41It is normal
11:43that mistakes are made.
11:45We saw it in the major matches
11:47of the European Champions League.
11:49Everything was discussed
11:51in the matches of Real Madrid and Barcelona.
11:53However,
11:55the repetition of mistakes
11:57makes the audience feel
11:59that there is something behind it.
12:01This is what made the university
12:03take this step
12:05to bring a judge
12:07who may solve this problem
12:09that Morocco is facing today.
12:11Indeed.
12:13Mr. Mohamed Mftah,
12:15journalist,
12:17thank you very much
12:19for joining us
12:21in this special segment
12:23of Ismail Fath's analysis
12:25on the development
12:27of football.